An Ambivalent Text: Chayan Samaddar

I heard that Children’s Literature was ’Impossible’, I heard it was an amorphous entity, I heard that there was no readily definable body of Children’s Literature any more than there is something that could be clearly labeled as Adult’s Literature. And, after going through Keneth Graham’s ‘The Wind in the Willows’ a couple of days back I am inclined to agree with everything I have heard. If this is Children’s Literature then William Golding’s ‘The Lord of the Flies’ should fall into the same category as well. However, this deeply ambivalent book has been dubbed as one of the undisputed classics in the field of Children’s Literature since its publication in 1908.

Apparently, this is an animal story: a series of misadventures by Mole, Rat, Badger and the irrepressible Toad. There is fun,frolic and burlesque. There is no sex or violence. Therefore, it must be a children’s book. What else can it be?  But, the very animals make one uneasy. They do not come across as animals at all. For all their superficial fur there is nothing ‘cute’ about the animals. Mole is a respectable householder, Badger is a country squire, Rat is a gentleman of leisure not much unlike Bertram Wooster and Toad is a moneyed land owner. This is a world of grown-ups with very grown up preoccupations. And what about those slow moving chapters like ‘DulceDomum’ or ‘The Piper at the Gates of Dawn’? How can a child ever identify with them?

One cursory glance at the Gates of Dawn would suffice to prove that we are in the midst of a Wordsworthian world. “A wide half circle of foam and glinting lights and shining shoulders of green water, the great weir closed the backwater from bank to bank, troubled all the quiet surface with twirling eddies and floating foam streaks and deadened all other sounds with its solemn and soothing rumble” .The language is strongly evocative of The Prelude! Then again, if one takes a look at the DulceDomum chapter he is certain to feel that here is an assemblage of fond emotional responses to the world of Reading : there are resonances of Wordsworth and Shelley, echoes of Charles Dickens. Here Mole asks Rat to make a play all but himself and dares him to act as mice are natural actors. It does not matter that he gets tongue tied and cannot perform. What matters is that Grahame evokes the enchantment of theatre, the seduction of role playing, the world of The Master of Shadows: William Shakespeare. But the Specter is contained almost as soon as it is raised for such histrionics has no place in the putatively domestic fantasy of ‘savory comfort’.

WND_13058093220This very longing for comfort brings to the fore a clash between two cultures. The Edwardian England and the stable Victorian World the author was brought up in. It is very easy to see that a fear of change permeates the book. One is almost forbidden to break out into the dangerous Wide World. And if anyone does break out, they are punished (symbolized by the Mole’s terror in the Wild Wood ) or regarded as bad (Toad is put behind the bars by the Law as well as locked away by his friends). It is not difficult to sense the author’s anxiety about the noisy, speedy, automobiles encroaching on the bucolic countryside and destroying the traditional ways of life, the growing strident voice of the working class and the recognition of women’s place in the society. For this reason Toad Hall is reclaimed by the forces of conventionalism, the deviant Toad is frowned upon and any reference to women is either derisive or condescending. Substituting sex with food here an anxious Englishman who fears women power tries to retreat into a rustic upper middle class idyll where all male bonding reigns supreme.

However, all said and done, nobody can gainsay this book’s appeal to children. Despite all the nuances a body of children did enjoy it across generations. Still does, as a matter of fact. The reason may be the farce, the burlesque or the image of Toad as an archetypal trickster. It can be a number of things which brings us back to square one. We cannot but resign ourselves to the fact that Great Literature knows no boundaries and resonating with a plethora of complex emotions can captivate just anybody.

Acknowledgement: 1) Children’s Literature—Peter Hunt

                                    2) Children’s Literature: A Very Short Introduction —Kimberley Reynolds.

                                   3) Children’s Literature: A Reader’s History from Aesop to Harry Potter—Seth Lerer.

About author

Chayan Samaddar
Chayan Samaddar 1 posts

Chayan Samaddar (b. 21.03.1972) is an avid reader. An English Teacher by profession Chayan is passionate about Literature and is extremely fond of Indian Classical Music and children. Chayan lives in Calcutta with his mother Smriti and wife Debanjana and gives vent to his feelings on his Facebook page চয়নের হিজিবিজি/Chayan's Scribblings.

You might also like

O Tempora! & Other Poems: Amit Chakravarty

Inside The Eyes of a Fortune-teller Inside the eyes of a fortune-teller lied a rural road. Then the evening was softly descending on the village. Vincent left painted cornfields on

Anathpindat & other Poems

Anathpindat* Rotten sea shell gashes your opium dream Before the morning prayer dance floor dishevels. While taking coffee in this bordello city Sleep evaporates from checkered table cloth. With cloud

The Testimony of God

Premashila’s seven-year-old son died on the train. Mother and son were travelling to their village from Hyderabad along with some daily-wage labourers whom she worked with in the city. The

The night train through Simultala: Vineet Iqbal Singh

I would start scavenging the house looking for the ancient, weather-bitten, faithful rucksack – signaling the end of my summer vacations. My itinerary would be in public domain – a

The Things That are Left & Other Poems

This Side, Alone The tune makes a suspect Whether it is ghostly enough The household mimics I set the debate on a tree-top   It gets fruitful Hey… Who else

Every day is Sunday: A Reading of The Sense of An Ending

“Every day is Sunday”…… as Tony wanted it to be. Once you open the book and start reading the novel, you will find the first line written, “I remember in

The Rain and Other Poems: Shankha Ghosh

Shankha Ghosh (born 6 February 1932) is a Bengali poet and critic, born in Chandpur of present day Bangladesh. He is a leading authority on Rabindranath Tagore. Other than that,

The Chemistry-Lover who doesn’t have a Nuclear Sense

As we returned from the proposed nuclear power plant, we carried a pamphlet with us. When we reached back our village, the electricity had stopped. I ran to the room

Escape: Saikat Baksi

He scooped up one triangular slice from the soft round pizza smothered with a molten crust of cheese. “Little more of oregano please” He told the young man at the


We know where we’re born, we can imagine where we will live and we don’t know where we will die. Well, I would say that I am surely in the

Scent of Women & Other Poems

The last line Two consecutive lines of a poem Always have an ego clash. Who’ll seat beneath? Who cares? No one wants to… But one has to sit. The succeeding

Revisiting Ritwik Kumar: Parthapratim Ghosh

“I & my Pen are same”. This line used to be synonymous with Ritwik Kumar Ghatak during his life time. Its the same line, we hear from Nilkantho Bagchi, the

Humans Without Borders: Atindriyo Chakraborty

The Bir Hors are a nomadic and traditionally hunting gathering tribe who number below 10,000 on this date, as per wiki wisdom. Presently, they have around sixteen settlements across Jharkhand

Thatcher’s Final Wash: Aaron Murdoch

You have no idea how much I shivered at stepping into this bath. It was under a bath that the bomb was hidden. It was the Brighton bomb. All the

Blues for a Black Cat

Boris Vian (1920-59) led a rather too short life on this earth. But, within that 39 years, he wrote 10 novels, 42 short stories, 7 theatre pieces, 400 songs, 4 poetry

Wind-script, Trigger Happy & Other Poems

1. Walk into the eerie; and sense who drills thy tomb with the wind-stone. 2. The propeller turns as a maze. On whose flesh that maroon nightgown murmurs? Oh human-toy!

Book & Film 0 Comments

Inception and the Philosophy of Mind

“Admit it. You no longer believe in one reality. So choose. Choose to be here. Choose me”. These enigmatic dialogues, directed towards Dominic Cobb are spoken by his subconscious which

‘Chera Cambiser Bag’: Review by Anirban Bhattacharya

…and the silence rolled up to a clandestine College Street junction, Subhas-da (Subhas Mukhopadhyay) cracked the silence with a soliloquy – ‘dekho bhebe dekhlam potrikata bodhoy hobe na’..(I think, the

Why Not A full Fledged One

I begin to offload. Not mere  clothes but  more . . . those  thoughts  hanging  about heavily. Stubbornly unmoving, intruding even now whilst I  am  trying to  cover this nakedness.

Sonauncle’s Home

A cycle was approaching on this late autumn afternoon. – Jugalchandra was sitting on the top tube with his legs dangling, the thin wind touching his eyebrows, hairs protruding from


No Comments Yet!

You can be first to comment this post!

Leave a Reply